Skip to content

Conversation

@mgilmore-relace
Copy link
Contributor

@mgilmore-relace mgilmore-relace commented Sep 24, 2025

What does this PR do?

The _handle_processing_tools_state added the same tool response twice when using interactions. See here and here.

Checklist Before Starting

  • Search for similar PRs. Paste at least one query link here: ...
  • Format the PR title as [{modules}] {type}: {description} (This will be checked by the CI)
    • {modules} include fsdp, megatron, sglang, vllm, rollout, trainer, ci, training_utils, recipe, hardware, deployment, ray, worker, single_controller, misc, perf, model, algo, env, tool, ckpt, doc, data
    • If this PR involves multiple modules, separate them with , like [megatron, fsdp, doc]
    • {type} is in feat, fix, refactor, chore, test
    • If this PR breaks any API (CLI arguments, config, function signature, etc.), add [BREAKING] to the beginning of the title.
    • Example: [BREAKING][fsdp, megatron] feat: dynamic batching

Test

For changes that can not be tested by CI (e.g., algorithm implementation, new model support), validate by experiment(s) and show results like training curve plots, evaluation results, etc.

API and Usage Example

Demonstrate how the API changes if any, and provide usage example(s) if possible.

# Add code snippet or script demonstrating how to use this

Design & Code Changes

Demonstrate the high-level design if this PR is complex, and list the specific changes.

Checklist Before Submitting

Important

Please check all the following items before requesting a review, otherwise the reviewer might deprioritize this PR for review.

Copy link
Contributor

@gemini-code-assist gemini-code-assist bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Code Review

This pull request aims to fix tool response duplication by removing a redundant code block. While this change is a step in the right direction and fixes one source of duplication when interactions are enabled, a more critical bug that also causes duplication remains in the _handle_processing_tools_state function.

The line agent_data.messages.extend(add_messages) at line 294 is incorrectly placed inside the for tool_response in responses: loop. This causes an incorrect number of messages to be added when multiple tools are called in a single turn. For N tool calls, it adds N*(N+1)/2 messages instead of N, with earlier messages being duplicated.

For example, with two tool calls, the messages list will be extended first with [message1] and then with [message1, message2], resulting in message1 being added twice.

The correct fix would be to move agent_data.messages.extend(add_messages) to after the loop finishes. I am pointing this out in this general summary as the affected line is outside the scope of the current changes. Given the severity, I strongly recommend addressing this in a follow-up PR. The current change is fine to merge as it does reduce some redundancy, but the core duplication issue for multiple tool calls persists.

@mgilmore-relace mgilmore-relace changed the title [rollout] {fix}: remove code responsible for tool response duplication [rollout] fix: remove code responsible for tool response duplication Sep 25, 2025
@wuxibin89 wuxibin89 merged commit 7731c5c into volcengine:main Sep 25, 2025
66 of 76 checks passed
masoudhashemi pushed a commit to masoudhashemi/verl that referenced this pull request Oct 19, 2025
…olcengine#3604)

### What does this PR do?

> The `_handle_processing_tools_state` added the same tool response
twice when using interactions. See
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/ba8555120af6a1f8dba8f09e60e4663ac5176efc/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L273)
and
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/ba8555120af6a1f8dba8f09e60e4663ac5176efc/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L297).

### Checklist Before Starting

- [x] Search for similar PRs. Paste at least one query link here: ...
- [x] Format the PR title as `[{modules}] {type}: {description}` (This
will be checked by the CI)
- `{modules}` include `fsdp`, `megatron`, `sglang`, `vllm`, `rollout`,
`trainer`, `ci`, `training_utils`, `recipe`, `hardware`, `deployment`,
`ray`, `worker`, `single_controller`, `misc`, `perf`, `model`, `algo`,
`env`, `tool`, `ckpt`, `doc`, `data`
- If this PR involves multiple modules, separate them with `,` like
`[megatron, fsdp, doc]`
  - `{type}` is in `feat`, `fix`, `refactor`, `chore`, `test`
- If this PR breaks any API (CLI arguments, config, function signature,
etc.), add `[BREAKING]` to the beginning of the title.
  - Example: `[BREAKING][fsdp, megatron] feat: dynamic batching`

### Test

> For changes that can not be tested by CI (e.g., algorithm
implementation, new model support), validate by experiment(s) and show
results like training curve plots, evaluation results, etc.

### API and Usage Example

> Demonstrate how the API changes if any, and provide usage example(s)
if possible.

```python
# Add code snippet or script demonstrating how to use this
```

### Design & Code Changes

> Demonstrate the high-level design if this PR is complex, and list the
specific changes.

### Checklist Before Submitting

> [!IMPORTANT]
> Please check all the following items before requesting a review,
otherwise the reviewer might deprioritize this PR for review.

- [ ] Read the [Contribute
Guide](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md).
- [ ] Apply [pre-commit
checks](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#code-linting-and-formatting):
`pre-commit install && pre-commit run --all-files --show-diff-on-failure
--color=always`
- [ ] Add / Update [the
documentation](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/docs).
- [ ] Add unit or end-to-end test(s) to [the CI
workflow](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/.github/workflows)
to cover all the code. If not feasible, explain why: ...
- [ ] Once your PR is ready for CI, send a message in [the `ci-request`
channel](https://verl-project.slack.com/archives/C091TCESWB1) in [the
`verl` Slack
workspace](https://join.slack.com/t/verl-project/shared_invite/zt-3855yhg8g-CTkqXu~hKojPCmo7k_yXTQ).
(If not accessible, please try [the Feishu group
(飞书群)](https://applink.larkoffice.com/client/chat/chatter/add_by_link?link_token=772jd4f1-cd91-441e-a820-498c6614126a).)
techkang pushed a commit to techkang/verl that referenced this pull request Oct 31, 2025
…olcengine#3604)

### What does this PR do?

> The `_handle_processing_tools_state` added the same tool response
twice when using interactions. See
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/ba8555120af6a1f8dba8f09e60e4663ac5176efc/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L273)
and
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/ba8555120af6a1f8dba8f09e60e4663ac5176efc/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L297).

### Checklist Before Starting

- [x] Search for similar PRs. Paste at least one query link here: ...
- [x] Format the PR title as `[{modules}] {type}: {description}` (This
will be checked by the CI)
- `{modules}` include `fsdp`, `megatron`, `sglang`, `vllm`, `rollout`,
`trainer`, `ci`, `training_utils`, `recipe`, `hardware`, `deployment`,
`ray`, `worker`, `single_controller`, `misc`, `perf`, `model`, `algo`,
`env`, `tool`, `ckpt`, `doc`, `data`
- If this PR involves multiple modules, separate them with `,` like
`[megatron, fsdp, doc]`
  - `{type}` is in `feat`, `fix`, `refactor`, `chore`, `test`
- If this PR breaks any API (CLI arguments, config, function signature,
etc.), add `[BREAKING]` to the beginning of the title.
  - Example: `[BREAKING][fsdp, megatron] feat: dynamic batching`

### Test

> For changes that can not be tested by CI (e.g., algorithm
implementation, new model support), validate by experiment(s) and show
results like training curve plots, evaluation results, etc.

### API and Usage Example

> Demonstrate how the API changes if any, and provide usage example(s)
if possible.

```python
# Add code snippet or script demonstrating how to use this
```

### Design & Code Changes

> Demonstrate the high-level design if this PR is complex, and list the
specific changes.

### Checklist Before Submitting

> [!IMPORTANT]
> Please check all the following items before requesting a review,
otherwise the reviewer might deprioritize this PR for review.

- [ ] Read the [Contribute
Guide](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md).
- [ ] Apply [pre-commit
checks](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#code-linting-and-formatting):
`pre-commit install && pre-commit run --all-files --show-diff-on-failure
--color=always`
- [ ] Add / Update [the
documentation](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/docs).
- [ ] Add unit or end-to-end test(s) to [the CI
workflow](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/.github/workflows)
to cover all the code. If not feasible, explain why: ...
- [ ] Once your PR is ready for CI, send a message in [the `ci-request`
channel](https://verl-project.slack.com/archives/C091TCESWB1) in [the
`verl` Slack
workspace](https://join.slack.com/t/verl-project/shared_invite/zt-3855yhg8g-CTkqXu~hKojPCmo7k_yXTQ).
(If not accessible, please try [the Feishu group
(飞书群)](https://applink.larkoffice.com/client/chat/chatter/add_by_link?link_token=772jd4f1-cd91-441e-a820-498c6614126a).)
mtian8 pushed a commit to mtian8/verl that referenced this pull request Nov 1, 2025
…olcengine#3604)

### What does this PR do?

> The `_handle_processing_tools_state` added the same tool response
twice when using interactions. See
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/ba8555120af6a1f8dba8f09e60e4663ac5176efc/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L273)
and
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/ba8555120af6a1f8dba8f09e60e4663ac5176efc/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L297).

### Checklist Before Starting

- [x] Search for similar PRs. Paste at least one query link here: ...
- [x] Format the PR title as `[{modules}] {type}: {description}` (This
will be checked by the CI)
- `{modules}` include `fsdp`, `megatron`, `sglang`, `vllm`, `rollout`,
`trainer`, `ci`, `training_utils`, `recipe`, `hardware`, `deployment`,
`ray`, `worker`, `single_controller`, `misc`, `perf`, `model`, `algo`,
`env`, `tool`, `ckpt`, `doc`, `data`
- If this PR involves multiple modules, separate them with `,` like
`[megatron, fsdp, doc]`
  - `{type}` is in `feat`, `fix`, `refactor`, `chore`, `test`
- If this PR breaks any API (CLI arguments, config, function signature,
etc.), add `[BREAKING]` to the beginning of the title.
  - Example: `[BREAKING][fsdp, megatron] feat: dynamic batching`

### Test

> For changes that can not be tested by CI (e.g., algorithm
implementation, new model support), validate by experiment(s) and show
results like training curve plots, evaluation results, etc.

### API and Usage Example

> Demonstrate how the API changes if any, and provide usage example(s)
if possible.

```python
# Add code snippet or script demonstrating how to use this
```

### Design & Code Changes

> Demonstrate the high-level design if this PR is complex, and list the
specific changes.

### Checklist Before Submitting

> [!IMPORTANT]
> Please check all the following items before requesting a review,
otherwise the reviewer might deprioritize this PR for review.

- [ ] Read the [Contribute
Guide](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md).
- [ ] Apply [pre-commit
checks](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#code-linting-and-formatting):
`pre-commit install && pre-commit run --all-files --show-diff-on-failure
--color=always`
- [ ] Add / Update [the
documentation](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/docs).
- [ ] Add unit or end-to-end test(s) to [the CI
workflow](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/.github/workflows)
to cover all the code. If not feasible, explain why: ...
- [ ] Once your PR is ready for CI, send a message in [the `ci-request`
channel](https://verl-project.slack.com/archives/C091TCESWB1) in [the
`verl` Slack
workspace](https://join.slack.com/t/verl-project/shared_invite/zt-3855yhg8g-CTkqXu~hKojPCmo7k_yXTQ).
(If not accessible, please try [the Feishu group
(飞书群)](https://applink.larkoffice.com/client/chat/chatter/add_by_link?link_token=772jd4f1-cd91-441e-a820-498c6614126a).)
wangboxiong320 pushed a commit to wangboxiong320/verl that referenced this pull request Nov 1, 2025
…olcengine#3604)

### What does this PR do?

> The `_handle_processing_tools_state` added the same tool response
twice when using interactions. See
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/d5e86c660b33fcf86010e110e81b73ff05fe1002/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L273)
and
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/d5e86c660b33fcf86010e110e81b73ff05fe1002/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L297).

### Checklist Before Starting

- [x] Search for similar PRs. Paste at least one query link here: ...
- [x] Format the PR title as `[{modules}] {type}: {description}` (This
will be checked by the CI)
- `{modules}` include `fsdp`, `megatron`, `sglang`, `vllm`, `rollout`,
`trainer`, `ci`, `training_utils`, `recipe`, `hardware`, `deployment`,
`ray`, `worker`, `single_controller`, `misc`, `perf`, `model`, `algo`,
`env`, `tool`, `ckpt`, `doc`, `data`
- If this PR involves multiple modules, separate them with `,` like
`[megatron, fsdp, doc]`
  - `{type}` is in `feat`, `fix`, `refactor`, `chore`, `test`
- If this PR breaks any API (CLI arguments, config, function signature,
etc.), add `[BREAKING]` to the beginning of the title.
  - Example: `[BREAKING][fsdp, megatron] feat: dynamic batching`

### Test

> For changes that can not be tested by CI (e.g., algorithm
implementation, new model support), validate by experiment(s) and show
results like training curve plots, evaluation results, etc.

### API and Usage Example

> Demonstrate how the API changes if any, and provide usage example(s)
if possible.

```python
# Add code snippet or script demonstrating how to use this
```

### Design & Code Changes

> Demonstrate the high-level design if this PR is complex, and list the
specific changes.

### Checklist Before Submitting

> [!IMPORTANT]
> Please check all the following items before requesting a review,
otherwise the reviewer might deprioritize this PR for review.

- [ ] Read the [Contribute
Guide](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md).
- [ ] Apply [pre-commit
checks](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#code-linting-and-formatting):
`pre-commit install && pre-commit run --all-files --show-diff-on-failure
--color=always`
- [ ] Add / Update [the
documentation](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/docs).
- [ ] Add unit or end-to-end test(s) to [the CI
workflow](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/.github/workflows)
to cover all the code. If not feasible, explain why: ...
- [ ] Once your PR is ready for CI, send a message in [the `ci-request`
channel](https://verl-project.slack.com/archives/C091TCESWB1) in [the
`verl` Slack
workspace](https://join.slack.com/t/verl-project/shared_invite/zt-3855yhg8g-CTkqXu~hKojPCmo7k_yXTQ).
(If not accessible, please try [the Feishu group
(飞书群)](https://applink.larkoffice.com/client/chat/chatter/add_by_link?link_token=772jd4f1-cd91-441e-a820-498c6614126a).)
chenjiaoAngel added a commit to chenjiaoAngel/verl that referenced this pull request Nov 14, 2025
…olcengine#3604)

### What does this PR do?

> The `_handle_processing_tools_state` added the same tool response
twice when using interactions. See
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/8aea3edebe7531089295330e8c4e03bbe7b656df/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L273)
and
[here](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/8aea3edebe7531089295330e8c4e03bbe7b656df/verl/experimental/agent_loop/tool_agent_loop.py#L297).

### Checklist Before Starting

- [x] Search for similar PRs. Paste at least one query link here: ...
- [x] Format the PR title as `[{modules}] {type}: {description}` (This
will be checked by the CI)
- `{modules}` include `fsdp`, `megatron`, `sglang`, `vllm`, `rollout`,
`trainer`, `ci`, `training_utils`, `recipe`, `hardware`, `deployment`,
`ray`, `worker`, `single_controller`, `misc`, `perf`, `model`, `algo`,
`env`, `tool`, `ckpt`, `doc`, `data`
- If this PR involves multiple modules, separate them with `,` like
`[megatron, fsdp, doc]`
  - `{type}` is in `feat`, `fix`, `refactor`, `chore`, `test`
- If this PR breaks any API (CLI arguments, config, function signature,
etc.), add `[BREAKING]` to the beginning of the title.
  - Example: `[BREAKING][fsdp, megatron] feat: dynamic batching`

### Test

> For changes that can not be tested by CI (e.g., algorithm
implementation, new model support), validate by experiment(s) and show
results like training curve plots, evaluation results, etc.

### API and Usage Example

> Demonstrate how the API changes if any, and provide usage example(s)
if possible.

```python
# Add code snippet or script demonstrating how to use this
```

### Design & Code Changes

> Demonstrate the high-level design if this PR is complex, and list the
specific changes.

### Checklist Before Submitting

> [!IMPORTANT]
> Please check all the following items before requesting a review,
otherwise the reviewer might deprioritize this PR for review.

- [ ] Read the [Contribute
Guide](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md).
- [ ] Apply [pre-commit
checks](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#code-linting-and-formatting):
`pre-commit install && pre-commit run --all-files --show-diff-on-failure
--color=always`
- [ ] Add / Update [the
documentation](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/docs).
- [ ] Add unit or end-to-end test(s) to [the CI
workflow](https://github.com/volcengine/verl/tree/main/.github/workflows)
to cover all the code. If not feasible, explain why: ...
- [ ] Once your PR is ready for CI, send a message in [the `ci-request`
channel](https://verl-project.slack.com/archives/C091TCESWB1) in [the
`verl` Slack
workspace](https://join.slack.com/t/verl-project/shared_invite/zt-3855yhg8g-CTkqXu~hKojPCmo7k_yXTQ).
(If not accessible, please try [the Feishu group
(飞书群)](https://applink.larkoffice.com/client/chat/chatter/add_by_link?link_token=772jd4f1-cd91-441e-a820-498c6614126a).)
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants