Handle config_settings as they would be passed by pip

changelog.d/3380.change.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
+Improved the handling of the ``config_settings`` parameter in both PEP 517 and
+PEP 660 interfaces:
+
+- It is possible now to pass both ``--global-option`` and ``--build-option``.
+  As discussed in #1928, arbitrary arguments passed via ``--global-option``
+  should be placed before the name of the setuptools' internal command, while
+  ``--build-option`` should come after.
+
+- Users can pass ``editable-mode=strict`` to select a strict behaviour for the
+  editable installation.

changelog.d/3380.deprecation.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+Passing some types of parameters via ``--global-option`` to setuptools PEP 517/PEP 660 backend
+is now considered deprecated. The user can pass the same arbitrary parameter
+via ``--build-option`` (``--global-option`` is now reserved for flags like
+``--verbose`` or ``--quiet``).
+
+Both ``--build-option`` and ``--global-option`` are supported as a **transitional** effort (a.k.a. "escape hatch").
+In the future a proper list of allowed ``config_settings`` may be created.

pytest.ini

@@ -60,3 +60,4 @@ filterwarnings=
 	ignore:Setuptools is replacing distutils
 
 	ignore:Support for project metadata in .pyproject.toml. is still experimental
+	ignore::setuptools.command.editable_wheel.InformationOnly

setuptools/build_meta.py

@@ -28,17 +28,21 @@
 
 import io
 import os
+import shlex
 import sys
 import tokenize
 import shutil
 import contextlib
 import tempfile
 import warnings
+from pathlib import Path
+from typing import Dict, Iterator, List, Optional, Union
 
 import setuptools
 import distutils
 from ._reqs import parse_strings
-from .extern.more_itertools import always_iterable
+from ._deprecation_warning import SetuptoolsDeprecationWarning
+from distutils.util import strtobool
 
 
 __all__ = ['get_requires_for_build_sdist',
@@ -129,33 +133,189 @@ def suppress_known_deprecation():
         yield
 
 
-class _BuildMetaBackend:
+_ConfigSettings = Optional[Dict[str, Union[str, List[str], None]]]
+"""
+Currently the user can run::
+
+    pip install -e . --config-settings key=value
+    python -m build -C--key=value -C key=value
+
+- pip will pass both key and value as strings and overwriting repeated keys
+  (pypa/pip#11059).
+- build will accumulate values associated with repeated keys in a list.
+  It will also accept keys with no associated value.
+  This means that an option passed by build can be ``str | list[str] | None``.
+- PEP 517 specifies that ``config_settings`` is an optional dict.
+"""
+
+
+class _ConfigSettingsTranslator:
+    """Translate ``config_settings`` into distutils-style command arguments.
+    Only a limited number of options is currently supported.
+    """
+    # See pypa/setuptools#1928 pypa/setuptools#2491
 
-    @staticmethod
-    def _fix_config(config_settings):
+    def _get_config(self, key: str, config_settings: _ConfigSettings) -> List[str]:
         """
-        Ensure config settings meet certain expectations.
-
-        >>> fc = _BuildMetaBackend._fix_config
-        >>> fc(None)
-        {'--global-option': []}
-        >>> fc({})
-        {'--global-option': []}
-        >>> fc({'--global-option': 'foo'})
-        {'--global-option': ['foo']}
-        >>> fc({'--global-option': ['foo']})
-        {'--global-option': ['foo']}
+        Get the value of a specific key in ``config_settings`` as a list of strings.
+
+        >>> fn = _ConfigSettingsTranslator()._get_config
+        >>> fn("--global-option", None)
+        []
+        >>> fn("--global-option", {})
+        []
+        >>> fn("--global-option", {'--global-option': 'foo'})
+        ['foo']
+        >>> fn("--global-option", {'--global-option': ['foo']})
+        ['foo']
+        >>> fn("--global-option", {'--global-option': 'foo'})
+        ['foo']
+        >>> fn("--global-option", {'--global-option': 'foo bar'})
+        ['foo', 'bar']
         """
-        config_settings = config_settings or {}
-        config_settings['--global-option'] = list(always_iterable(
-            config_settings.get('--global-option')))
-        return config_settings
+        cfg = config_settings or {}
+        opts = cfg.get(key) or []
+        return shlex.split(opts) if isinstance(opts, str) else opts
 
-    def _get_build_requires(self, config_settings, requirements):
-        config_settings = self._fix_config(config_settings)
+    def _valid_global_options(self):
+        """Global options accepted by setuptools (e.g. quiet or verbose)."""
+        options = (opt[:2] for opt in setuptools.dist.Distribution.global_options)
+        return {flag for long_and_short in options for flag in long_and_short if flag}
+
+    def _global_args(self, config_settings: _ConfigSettings) -> Iterator[str]:
+        """
+        Let the user specify ``verbose`` or ``quiet`` + escape hatch via
+        ``--global-option``.
+        Note: ``-v``, ``-vv``, ``-vvv`` have similar effects in setuptools,
+        so we just have to cover the basic scenario ``-v``.
+
+        >>> fn = _ConfigSettingsTranslator()._global_args
+        >>> list(fn(None))
+        []
+        >>> list(fn({"verbose": "False"}))
+        ['-q']
+        >>> list(fn({"verbose": "1"}))
+        ['-v']
+        >>> list(fn({"--verbose": None}))
+        ['-v']
+        >>> list(fn({"verbose": "true", "--global-option": "-q --no-user-cfg"}))
+        ['-v', '-q', '--no-user-cfg']
+        >>> list(fn({"--quiet": None}))
+        ['-q']
+        """
+        cfg = config_settings or {}
+        falsey = {"false", "no", "0", "off"}
+        if "verbose" in cfg or "--verbose" in cfg:
+            level = str(cfg.get("verbose") or cfg.get("--verbose") or "1")
+            yield ("-q" if level.lower() in falsey else "-v")
+        if "quiet" in cfg or "--quiet" in cfg:
+            level = str(cfg.get("quiet") or cfg.get("--quiet") or "1")
+            yield ("-v" if level.lower() in falsey else "-q")
+
+        valid = self._valid_global_options()
+        args = self._get_config("--global-option", config_settings)
+        yield from (arg for arg in args if arg.strip("-") in valid)
+
+    def __dist_info_args(self, config_settings: _ConfigSettings) -> Iterator[str]:
+        """
+        The ``dist_info`` command accepts ``tag-date`` and ``tag-build``.
+
+        .. warning::
+           We cannot use this yet as it requires the ``sdist`` and ``bdist_wheel``
+           commands run in ``build_sdist`` and ``build_wheel`` to re-use the egg-info
+           directory created in ``prepare_metadata_for_build_wheel``.
+
+        >>> fn = _ConfigSettingsTranslator()._ConfigSettingsTranslator__dist_info_args
+        >>> list(fn(None))
+        []
+        >>> list(fn({"tag-date": "False"}))
+        ['--no-date']
+        >>> list(fn({"tag-date": None}))
+        ['--no-date']
+        >>> list(fn({"tag-date": "true", "tag-build": ".a"}))
+        ['--tag-date', '--tag-build', '.a']
+        """
+        cfg = config_settings or {}
+        if "tag-date" in cfg:
+            val = strtobool(str(cfg["tag-date"] or "false"))
+            yield ("--tag-date" if val else "--no-date")
+        if "tag-build" in cfg:
+            yield from ["--tag-build", str(cfg["tag-build"])]
+
+    def _editable_args(self, config_settings: _ConfigSettings) -> Iterator[str]:
+        """
+        The ``editable_wheel`` command accepts ``editable-mode=strict``.
+
+        >>> fn = _ConfigSettingsTranslator()._editable_args
+        >>> list(fn(None))
+        []
+        >>> list(fn({"editable-mode": "strict"}))
+        ['--strict']
+        >>> list(fn({"editable-mode": "other"}))
+        Traceback (most recent call last):
+           ...
+        ValueError: Invalid value for `editable-mode`: 'other'. Try: 'strict'.
+        """
+        cfg = config_settings or {}
+        if "editable-mode" not in cfg and "editable_mode" not in cfg:
+            return
+        mode = cfg.get("editable-mode") or cfg.get("editable_mode")
+        if mode != "strict":
+            msg = f"Invalid value for `editable-mode`: {mode!r}. Try: 'strict'."
+            raise ValueError(msg)
+        yield "--strict"
+
+    def _arbitrary_args(self, config_settings: _ConfigSettings) -> Iterator[str]:
+        """
+        Users may expect to pass arbitrary lists of arguments to a command
+        via "--global-option" (example provided in PEP 517 of a "escape hatch").
+
+        >>> fn = _ConfigSettingsTranslator()._arbitrary_args
+        >>> list(fn(None))
+        []
+        >>> list(fn({}))
+        []
+        >>> list(fn({'--build-option': 'foo'}))
+        ['foo']
+        >>> list(fn({'--build-option': ['foo']}))
+        ['foo']
+        >>> list(fn({'--build-option': 'foo'}))
+        ['foo']
+        >>> list(fn({'--build-option': 'foo bar'}))
+        ['foo', 'bar']
+        >>> warnings.simplefilter('error', SetuptoolsDeprecationWarning)
+        >>> list(fn({'--global-option': 'foo'}))  # doctest: +IGNORE_EXCEPTION_DETAIL
+        Traceback (most recent call last):
+        SetuptoolsDeprecationWarning: ...arguments given via `--global-option`...
+        """
+        args = self._get_config("--global-option", config_settings)
+        global_opts = self._valid_global_options()
+        bad_args = []
+
+        for arg in args:
+            if arg.strip("-") not in global_opts:
+                bad_args.append(arg)
+                yield arg
 
-        sys.argv = sys.argv[:1] + ['egg_info'] + \
-            config_settings["--global-option"]
+        yield from self._get_config("--build-option", config_settings)
+
+        if bad_args:
+            msg = f"""
+            The arguments {bad_args!r} were given via `--global-option`.
+            Please use `--build-option` instead,
+            `--global-option` is reserved to flags like `--verbose` or `--quiet`.
+            """
+            warnings.warn(msg, SetuptoolsDeprecationWarning)
+
+
+class _BuildMetaBackend(_ConfigSettingsTranslator):
+    def _get_build_requires(self, config_settings, requirements):
+        sys.argv = [
+            *sys.argv[:1],
+            *self._global_args(config_settings),
+            "egg_info",
+            *self._arbitrary_args(config_settings),
+        ]
         try:
             with Distribution.patch():
                 self.run_setup()
@@ -176,16 +336,19 @@ def run_setup(self, setup_script='setup.py'):
         exec(compile(code, __file__, 'exec'), locals())
 
     def get_requires_for_build_wheel(self, config_settings=None):
-        return self._get_build_requires(
-            config_settings, requirements=['wheel'])
+        return self._get_build_requires(config_settings, requirements=['wheel'])
 
     def get_requires_for_build_sdist(self, config_settings=None):
         return self._get_build_requires(config_settings, requirements=[])
 
     def prepare_metadata_for_build_wheel(self, metadata_directory,
                                          config_settings=None):
-        sys.argv = sys.argv[:1] + [
-            'dist_info', '--output-dir', metadata_directory]
+        sys.argv = [
+            *sys.argv[:1],
+            *self._global_args(config_settings),
+            "dist_info",
+            "--output-dir", metadata_directory,
+        ]
         with no_install_setup_requires():
             self.run_setup()
 
@@ -218,15 +381,18 @@ def prepare_metadata_for_build_wheel(self, metadata_directory,
 
     def _build_with_temp_dir(self, setup_command, result_extension,
                              result_directory, config_settings):
-        config_settings = self._fix_config(config_settings)
         result_directory = os.path.abspath(result_directory)
 
         # Build in a temporary directory, then copy to the target.
         os.makedirs(result_directory, exist_ok=True)
         with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory(dir=result_directory) as tmp_dist_dir:
-            sys.argv = (sys.argv[:1] + setup_command +
-                        ['--dist-dir', tmp_dist_dir] +
-                        config_settings["--global-option"])
+            sys.argv = [
+                *sys.argv[:1],
+                *self._global_args(config_settings),
+                *setup_command,
+                "--dist-dir", tmp_dist_dir,
+                *self._arbitrary_args(config_settings),
+            ]
             with no_install_setup_requires():
                 self.run_setup()
 
@@ -251,6 +417,13 @@ def build_sdist(self, sdist_directory, config_settings=None):
                                          '.tar.gz', sdist_directory,
                                          config_settings)
 
+    def _get_dist_info_dir(self, metadata_directory: Optional[str]) -> Optional[str]:
+        if not metadata_directory:
+            return None
+        dist_info_candidates = list(Path(metadata_directory).glob("*.dist-info"))
+        assert len(dist_info_candidates) <= 1
+        return str(dist_info_candidates[0]) if dist_info_candidates else None
+
     # PEP660 hooks:
     # build_editable
     # get_requires_for_build_editable
@@ -259,10 +432,10 @@ def build_editable(
         self, wheel_directory, config_settings=None, metadata_directory=None
     ):
         # XXX can or should we hide our editable_wheel command normally?
-        return self._build_with_temp_dir(
-            ["editable_wheel", "--dist-info-dir", metadata_directory],
-            ".whl", wheel_directory, config_settings
-        )
+        info_dir = self._get_dist_info_dir(metadata_directory)
+        opts = ["--dist-info-dir", info_dir] if info_dir else []
+        cmd = ["editable_wheel", *opts, *self._editable_args(config_settings)]
+        return self._build_with_temp_dir(cmd, ".whl", wheel_directory, config_settings)
 
     def get_requires_for_build_editable(self, config_settings=None):
         return self.get_requires_for_build_wheel(config_settings)

setuptools/command/dist_info.py

@@ -25,13 +25,21 @@ class dist_info(Command):
                            " DEPRECATED: use --output-dir."),
         ('output-dir=', 'o', "directory inside of which the .dist-info will be"
                              "created (default: top of the source tree)"),
+        ('tag-date', 'd', "Add date stamp (e.g. 20050528) to version number"),
+        ('tag-build=', 'b', "Specify explicit tag to add to version number"),
+        ('no-date', 'D', "Don't include date stamp [default]"),
     ]
 
+    boolean_options = ['tag-date']
+    negative_opt = {'no-date': 'tag-date'}
+
     def initialize_options(self):
         self.egg_base = None
         self.output_dir = None
         self.name = None
         self.dist_info_dir = None
+        self.tag_date = None
+        self.tag_build = None
 
     def finalize_options(self):
         if self.egg_base:
@@ -43,8 +51,19 @@ def finalize_options(self):
         project_dir = dist.src_root or os.curdir
         self.output_dir = Path(self.output_dir or project_dir)
 
-        egg_info = self.reinitialize_command('egg_info')
+        egg_info = self.reinitialize_command("egg_info")
         egg_info.egg_base = str(self.output_dir)
+
+        if self.tag_date:
+            egg_info.tag_date = self.tag_date
+        else:
+            self.tag_date = egg_info.tag_date
+
+        if self.tag_build:
+            egg_info.tag_build = self.tag_build
+        else:
+            self.tag_build = egg_info.tag_build
+
         egg_info.finalize_options()
         self.egg_info = egg_info