Skip to content

Review Namada Ledger app transaction formatting #3500

@murisi

Description

@murisi

Review scope

Could we review the following details pertaining to the Namada Ledger app test vectors generated by #3494?:

  • Transaction coverage: are all the desired transaction types generated by the test vector generator?
  • Variation coverage: are all possible variations (enum variants) of each transaction generated by the vector generator?
  • Display coverage: are all fields of a given transaction displayed in expert mode without any omission?
  • User-friendliness of the normal mode:
    • Is too much information being displayed for the average user?
    • Are the relevant details of each transaction being printed in normal mode?
    • Are the outputs in normal mode being ordered sensibly?
    • Are there better ways of grouping/organizing the normal mode outputs? (Especially for Transfers)

Current transaction coverage

The following list enumerates the transactions currently covered by the test vector generator. Is anything missing?

  • TX_CHANGE_METADATA_WASM - pos::MetaDataChange
  • TX_REVEAL_PK - common::PublicKey
  • TX_CHANGE_CONSENSUS_KEY_WASM - ConsensusKeyChange
  • TX_CHANGE_COMMISSION_WASM - pos::CommissionChange
  • TX_UPDATE_STEWARD_COMMISSION - UpdateStewardCommission
  • TX_UNJAIL_VALIDATOR_WASM - Address
  • TX_DEACTIVATE_VALIDATOR_WASM - Address
  • TX_REACTIVATE_VALIDATOR_WASM - Address
  • TX_RESIGN_STEWARD - Address
  • TX_REDELEGATE_WASM - pos::Redelegation
  • TX_WITHDRAW_WASM - pos::Withdraw
  • TX_CLAIM_REWARDS_WASM - pos::ClaimRewards
  • TX_UNBOND_WASM - pos::Unbond
  • TX_BOND_WASM - pos::Bond
  • TX_INIT_PROPOSAL - InitProposalData
  • TX_VOTE_PROPOSAL - VoteProposalData
  • TX_BECOME_VALIDATOR_WASM - BecomeValidator
  • TX_INIT_ACCOUNT_WASM - InitAccount
  • TX_UPDATE_ACCOUNT_WASM - UpdateAccount
  • TX_TRANSFER_WASM - Transfer
  • TX_IBC_WASM - MsgTransfer
  • TX_IBC_WASM - MsgNftTransfer
  • TX_BRIDGE_POOL_WASM - PendingTransfer

Test vectors

Please find attached the generated test vectors in the JSON file. I've also attached the debug prints and transaction schemas in case this is relevant.
vectors.json
schema.txt
debugs.txt.gz

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions