Drop deprecated InfFE::n_dofs(), n_shape_functions() taking an ElemType #4337
Conversation
|
I decided to split the removal of the deprecated The deprecation dates here are somewhat inconsistent, for example sometimes we would deprecate a lower-level API, but forget to deprecate the higher-level APIs that called the lower-level ones until much later, even though they were "effectively" also deprecated the entire time. Everything removed in this branch was effectively deprecated in at least the 1.8.x series, and sometimes much earlier. |
These functions have been marked libmesh_deprecated() since 1ec8fcd (Jun 2020), in release series 1.6.x and later. This removal also triggers the removal of the FEInterface functions ifem_n_shape_functions() and ifem_n_dofs() since they called the version of InfFE::n_dofs() which is being removed. Technically, these FEInterface functions have not been marked libmesh_deprecated() for quite as long (a133c3d, Feb 2025) but they have *effectively* been deprecated for just as long. To avoid also dropping the deprecated FE APIs with the same names, we've simply placed libmesh_not_implemented() error messages in those deprecated functions for now to handle the infinite Elem case. This seems like a reasonable compromise to avoid dropping both the FE and InfFE deprecated functions at the same time.
jwpeterson
force-pushed
the
drop_deprecated_inf_fe_n_dofs
branch
from
ed5468f to
450fc1b
Compare
|
Job Coverage, step Generate coverage on 450fc1b wanted to post the following: CoverageInconsistent report tags were found between the head and base reports. Inconsistent tags: This comment will be updated on new commits. |
3 participants
These functions have been marked libmesh_deprecated() since 1ec8fcd (Jun 2020), in release series 1.6.x and later.
This removal also triggers the removal of the FEInterface functions ifem_n_shape_functions() and ifem_n_dofs() since they called the version of InfFE::n_dofs() which is being removed. Technically, these FEInterface functions have not been marked libmesh_deprecated() for quite as long (a133c3d, Feb 2025) but they have effectively been deprecated for just as long.
To avoid also dropping the deprecated FE APIs with the same names, we've simply placed libmesh_not_implemented() error messages in those deprecated functions for now to handle the infinite Elem case. This seems like a reasonable compromise to avoid dropping both the FE and InfFE deprecated functions at the same time.