Tracking issue for reverted transaction that should succeed on EVM 2024-12

[dmitrylavrenov]

This is a tracking issue for investigating the reason of reverted transaction that should succeed on EVM, getting root cause, reproducing the issue, implementing a proper fix.

---

Bugfix PRs:

• Add missing on_created_account logic usage for inc_account_nonce at pallet-evm-system frontier#147
• Properly manage contract accounts creation and removal logic frontier#140

Internal playground utils:

• https://github.com/humanode-network/humanode-playground/pull/70

[dmitrylavrenov]

succeded transaction:

• trx: https://humanode.subscan.io/tx/0x722c86b6daa736487b5ade80d659cc91cdfcf62f3809a25f0ccf90726e341d9b
• exported state at https://humanode.subscan.io/block/7927643
• patched state to be able run dev mode with sudo non-zero alice
• run humanode-peer on 7927643 state => resubmitted transaction => success
• run humanode-peer on 7927643 state => run runtime upgrade to v0.0.0-it6-2024-10-17 (current mainnet) => resubmitted transaction => success
• run humanode-peer on 7927643 state => run runtime upgrade to current draft polkadot-v0.9.43 => resubmitted transaction => success

failed transaction:

• trx: https://humanode.subscan.io/tx/0x332e1eb3400fb9654775f5916ce2cdb74a9c309e2ffd99009df558672c47ab04
• exported state at https://humanode.subscan.io/block/10507907
• patched state to be able run dev mode with sudo non-zero alice
• run humanode-peer on 10507907 state => resubmitted transaction => reverted
• run humanode-peer on 10507907 state => run runtime upgrade to current draft polkadot-v0.9.43 => resubmitted transaction => reverted

[dmitrylavrenov]

• prepared the humanode-peer version with enabled debug of evm opcodes operation taking into account the value of left gas
• rerun the same process as above for succeeded (block number 7927643) and failed (block number 10507907) transactions

logs-7927643.txt
logs-10507907.txt

[dmitrylavrenov]

• added more debug logs
• discovered the root cause why is the failed transaction reverted

There is a broken nonce in our state for 0xf803e8ca755ae4770b5e6072a1e3cb97631d76ee contract address

[dmitrylavrenov]

The block containing transactions that resulted into 0xf803e8ca755ae4770b5e6072a1e3cb97631d76ee contract account killing - https://humanode.subscan.io/extrinsic/7969497-1

Note: all contract tokens have been withdrawn

[dmitrylavrenov]

Implemented E2E test that reproduces the issue - #1398