HKSV does not work in HomeKit camera proxy mode

[bgoncal]

I have my Aqara G4 doorbell in Apple Home through go2rtc, I have enabled recording on any movement (in HomeKit secure video), but nothing was recorded till now (a few hours using).

Is HKSV really supported?

[AlexxIT]

Proxy logic fixed in latest master version. I'm not using HKSV, so can't test it.

[brb408wpb]

I am having a similar problem. I haven't "fully" installed the device yet, because I want to make sure it is working or I will send it back. From the troubleshooting tips I have found, such as removing the doorbell from the Aqara and HK app, it still won't stream and record. 2TB iCloud plan 128gb SD card, no batteries, wired to a 12v source, firmware current at 4.0.4, HK either on a current HomePod mini or AppleTV. Activity history either off or One Month. If I don't get this working soon, I will send it back. I know HKSV works for me because I can do it from a Wyze camera streamed through Scrypted.

[bgoncal]

Proxy logic fixed in latest master version. I'm not using HKSV, so can't test it.

Until this moment, nothing recorded

[AlexxIT]

I don't understand if problem solved or not

[heroash88]

First, THANK YOU Alex!! The proxy feature is AMAZING.

Second, I am having the same problem. I tested on multiple cameras: 2 Aqara G3s, Aqara G2H, Aqara G2H Pro, and an Ecobee Camera.

Happy to help test if you decided to work on a fix.

[bgoncal]

I don't understand if problem solved or not

The problem was not solved, I still don't see recordings in Apple Home app, neither on Aqara G4 or G3

[AlexxIT]

Unfortunately I can't pay for iCloud even for a test. Payment systems are blocked in the country.

[bgoncal]

Unfortunately I can't pay for iCloud even for a test. Payment systems are blocked in the country.

Is there anything that I or @heroash88 could help as a user?

[AlexxIT]

I guess I need to see live how the data is transferred to understand the problem.
As I know, HKSV can be enabled only for paid accounts.

[AbsolutJohan]

I've got the same situation with my cameras. Can't get any of them (proxied Eve cameras and Reolink cameras) to record anything after adding them in Apple Home. Get the option when adding them to record and have enabled it but there's no recording being saved on Apples servers.
The only time it's working is if I'm adding the HomeKit cameras directly to Apple Home but I really wanna get them in Home Assistant and Go2RTC. Recordings working through other HKSV application, for example Scrypted.

Has anyone got the recordings working on Go2RTC?
Also, awesome job

[AlexxIT]

@AbsolutJohan you got not same situation. Go2rtc doesn't support HKSV for 3rd party cameras. This issue about HomeKit cameras.

[AbsolutJohan]

@AbsolutJohan you got not same situation. Go2rtc doesn't support HKSV for 3rd party cameras. This issue about HomeKit cameras.

Im sorry, then I understand why some doesn’t work but the Eve indoor and outdoor cameras that I have has native support for HKSV. So I suppose the idea is that they are supposed to work as proxied HomeKit cameras with HKSV in Go2RTC