Skip to content

KR_COMPLETION_CHECKLIST.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
518 lines (399 loc) · 13.7 KB

KR_COMPLETION_CHECKLIST.md

File metadata and controls

518 lines (399 loc) · 13.7 KB

K&R C Book Completion Checklist

Goal: Complete all remaining K&R C (2nd Edition) language constructs to achieve 95%+ coverage Current Progress: 116/150 constructs (77% complete) Target: 143/150 constructs (95% complete) Remaining: 34 constructs to implement/document

Progress Overview

Category Total Completed Remaining % Complete
Data Types 15 15 0 100% ✅
Operators 25 24 1 96% ⏳
Statements 12 12 0 100% ✅
Functions 10 10 0 100% ✅
Memory Management 8 8 0 100% ✅
String & I/O 12 11 1 92% ⏳
Preprocessor 20 6 14 30% ❌
Advanced Features 18 5 13 28% ❌
C99 Specific 30 25 5 83% ⏳
TOTAL 150 116 34 77%

Remaining Tasks by Priority

🔴 HIGH PRIORITY (Complete These First)

1. Preprocessor Directives (14 remaining)

Why Critical: Essential for real-world C code (headers, platform-specific code)

  • ❌ Complex Macro Expansion (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.3, C99 §6.10.3
    • C: #define MAX(a,b) ((a)>(b)?(a):(b))
    • Rust: macro_rules! or inline functions
    • Priority: CRITICAL
    • Story Points: 13

  • ❌ Conditional Compilation (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.4, C99 §6.10.1
    • C: #if, #elif, #else, #endif
    • Rust: cfg!, #[cfg(...)]
    • Priority: CRITICAL
    • Story Points: 8

  • ❌ Advanced #ifdef/#ifndef (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.5, C99 §6.10.1
    • C: Nested conditional compilation
    • Rust: Feature flags, cfg attributes
    • Priority: HIGH
    • Story Points: 5

  • ❌ #pragma Directives (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.8, C99 §6.10.6
    • C: #pragma pack, #pragma once
    • Rust: #[repr(packed)], path-based module system
    • Priority: HIGH
    • Story Points: 8

  • ❌ Macro Stringification (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.3.3, C99 §6.10.3.2
    • C: #define STR(x) #x
    • Rust: stringify! macro
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 3

  • ❌ Token Pasting (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.3.4, C99 §6.10.3.3
    • C: #define CONCAT(a,b) a##b
    • Rust: Complex macro expansion
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 5

  • ❌ Predefined Macros (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.2, C99 §6.10.8
    • C: __FILE__, __LINE__, __DATE__
    • Rust: file!(), line!(), compile-time constants
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 3

  • ❌ #undef Directive (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.6, C99 §6.10.6
    • C: Undefine macros
    • Rust: Module scoping
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ #error Directive (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C99 §6.10.5
    • C: Compile-time errors
    • Rust: compile_error! macro
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ #warning Directive (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: GCC extension
    • C: Compile-time warnings
    • Rust: Custom derive warnings
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ Line Control (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.7, C99 §6.10.4
    • C: #line directive
    • Rust: Debug info preservation
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ Macro Variadic Arguments (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C99 §6.10.3
    • C: #define LOG(...) printf(__VA_ARGS__)
    • Rust: macro_rules! with repetition
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 5

  • ❌ Include Guards (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.1
    • C: #ifndef HEADER_H pattern
    • Rust: Module system (no guards needed)
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ Recursive Macro Expansion (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A12.3.5
    • C: Self-referential macros
    • Rust: Complex declarative macros
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 8

Preprocessor Subtotal: 14 tasks, 68 story points

2. File I/O Completion (1 remaining)

Why Critical: Chapter 7 completion

  • ⏳ scanf Family (DECY-XXX) - 80% complete
    • Reference: K&R §7.4, C99 §7.19.6.2
    • C: scanf, fscanf, sscanf
    • Rust: String parsing + pattern matching
    • Priority: HIGH
    • Story Points: 5
    • Remaining: Complex format specifiers

File I/O Subtotal: 1 task, 5 story points

🟡 MEDIUM PRIORITY (Important for Coverage)

3. Advanced C99 Features (5 remaining)

  • ❌ Complex Numbers (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C99 §6.2.5.11, §7.3
    • C: _Complex, complex.h
    • Rust: num-complex crate
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 8

  • ⏳ Hexadecimal Float Literals (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: C99 §6.4.4.2
    • C: 0x1.fp10
    • Rust: Manual conversion
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 3

  • ⏳ restrict Keyword (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: C99 §6.7.3.1
    • C: Pointer aliasing hint
    • Rust: No direct equivalent (borrow checker handles this)
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ⏳ inline Keyword (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: C99 §6.7.4
    • C: Inline function hint
    • Rust: #[inline] attribute
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ Variable-Length Arrays (VLA) - Full Support (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C99 §6.7.5.2
    • C: int arr[n] where n is runtime value
    • Rust: Vec<T> or heap allocation
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 5
    • Current: Basic support exists, needs edge cases

C99 Subtotal: 5 tasks, 20 story points

4. Advanced Features (13 remaining)

  • ⏳ goto Statements (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: K&R §3.8, C99 §6.8.6.1
    • C: goto label;
    • Rust: Loop labels with break/continue
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 3

  • ❌ setjmp/longjmp (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §B9, C99 §7.13
    • C: Non-local jumps
    • Rust: Result<T> + early returns, or catch_unwind
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 8

  • ❌ Signal Handling (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §B10, C99 §7.14
    • C: signal, raise
    • Rust: signal-hook crate or channels
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 8

  • ❌ Bit Fields (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §6.9, C99 §6.7.2.1
    • C: struct { unsigned int x:3; }
    • Rust: Manual bit manipulation or bitflags crate
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 8

  • ⏳ Flexible Array Members (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: C99 §6.7.2.1
    • C: struct { int n; int data[]; }
    • Rust: Vec<T> or unsafe with custom allocator
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 5

  • ⏳ Compound Literals (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: C99 §6.5.2.5
    • C: (struct Point){.x=1, .y=2}
    • Rust: Struct literals
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 3

  • ⏳ Designated Initializers (DECY-XXX) - Documentation only

    • Reference: C99 §6.7.8
    • C: int arr[10] = {[5]=10, [7]=20}
    • Rust: Manual array construction
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 3

  • ❌ Volatile Semantics (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A8.2, C99 §6.7.3
    • C: volatile int *ptr
    • Rust: core::ptr::read_volatile, write_volatile
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 5

  • ❌ Register Keyword (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: K&R §A8.1, C99 §6.7.1
    • C: register int x;
    • Rust: Ignored (LLVM optimizes)
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 1

  • ❌ Static Assertions (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C11 §6.7.10
    • C: _Static_assert(sizeof(int)==4, "msg")
    • Rust: static_assertions crate or const assertions
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 2

  • ❌ Atomic Operations (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C11 §7.17
    • C: _Atomic, atomic operations
    • Rust: std::sync::atomic
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 8

  • ❌ Thread-Local Storage (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C11 §6.7.1
    • C: _Thread_local
    • Rust: thread_local! macro
    • Priority: MEDIUM
    • Story Points: 5

  • ❌ Alignment Specifiers (DECY-XXX)

    • Reference: C11 §6.7.5
    • C: _Alignas(16)
    • Rust: #[repr(align(16))]
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 3

Advanced Features Subtotal: 13 tasks, 62 story points

🟢 LOW PRIORITY (Nice to Have)

5. Cast Operators (1 remaining)

  • ⏳ Complex Type Casts (DECY-XXX) - 80% complete
    • Reference: K&R §6.5, C99 §6.5.4
    • C: Function pointer casts, union type punning
    • Rust: std::mem::transmute (unsafe)
    • Priority: LOW
    • Story Points: 3

Cast Operators Subtotal: 1 task, 3 story points

Implementation Roadmap

Sprint 8: Preprocessor Foundation (2 weeks)

Goal: Enable basic real-world C header parsing

  • DECY-XXX: Complex macro expansion (13 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Conditional compilation (#if/#ifdef) (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Macro variadic arguments (5 points)
  • Total: 26 story points

Acceptance Criteria:

  • Parse common C headers (stdio.h, stdlib.h snippets)
  • Handle platform-specific #ifdef blocks
  • Variadic printf-like macros work

Sprint 9: File I/O + Advanced Preprocessor (2 weeks)

Goal: Complete Chapter 7, enhance preprocessor

  • DECY-XXX: scanf family completion (5 points)
  • DECY-XXX: #pragma directives (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Token pasting (##) (5 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Advanced #ifdef/#ifndef (5 points)
  • Total: 23 story points

Acceptance Criteria:

  • All Chapter 7 I/O functions supported
  • Header guard patterns recognized
  • Platform-specific code handled

Sprint 10: Advanced Features Part 1 (2 weeks)

Goal: Bit fields, signals, setjmp/longjmp

  • DECY-XXX: Bit fields (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Signal handling (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: setjmp/longjmp (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Volatile semantics (5 points)
  • Total: 29 story points

Acceptance Criteria:

  • Struct bit fields → Rust bit manipulation
  • signal() → Rust signal handling
  • Error handling with setjmp → Result

Sprint 11: Advanced Features Part 2 (2 weeks)

Goal: Atomics, threading, complex numbers

  • DECY-XXX: Complex numbers (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Atomic operations (8 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Thread-local storage (5 points)
  • DECY-XXX: goto statements (3 points)
  • DECY-XXX: VLA full support (5 points)
  • Total: 29 story points

Acceptance Criteria:

  • C complex.h → num-complex crate
  • C11 atomics → std::sync::atomic
  • TLS → thread_local! macro

Sprint 12: Cleanup & Polish (2 weeks)

Goal: Complete remaining low-priority items

  • DECY-XXX: All remaining preprocessor tasks (16 points)
  • DECY-XXX: All remaining C99/C11 tasks (10 points)
  • DECY-XXX: Cast operators completion (3 points)
  • Total: 29 story points

Acceptance Criteria:

  • 95%+ K&R coverage achieved
  • All documentation complete
  • Real-world C project validation

Success Metrics

Target Coverage by Sprint

Sprint Constructs Complete Coverage % Cumulative Story Points
Current (7) 116/150 77% 217
Sprint 8 119/150 79% 243
Sprint 9 123/150 82% 266
Sprint 10 127/150 85% 295
Sprint 11 132/150 88% 324
Sprint 12 143/150 95% ✅ 353

Quality Requirements (All Sprints)

  • ✅ Coverage ≥80% (target: 90%+)
  • ✅ Clippy warnings = 0
  • ✅ SATD comments = 0
  • ✅ Unsafe per 1000 LOC <5
  • ✅ All tests passing
  • ✅ Documentation complete

Test Requirements Per Task

Each task must include:

  1. Unit Tests (≥5 per feature)

    • Basic functionality
    • Edge cases
    • Error handling

  2. Property Tests (≥3 per feature)

    • Invariants hold across random inputs
    • 256 cases per property minimum

  3. Documentation Tests (≥2 per feature)

    • C code example
    • Expected Rust output
    • Explanation of transformation

  4. Integration Tests (≥1 per feature)

    • End-to-end transpilation
    • Verification that generated Rust compiles
    • Unsafe block count validation

Validation Strategy

Book-Based Validation

For each construct:

  1. Find example in K&R book (cite page/section)
  2. Create test case with exact K&R code
  3. Document expected Rust equivalent
  4. Verify transpiled output matches
  5. Check for STOP THE LINE conditions

Reference Documentation

  • Primary: K&R C (2nd Edition)
  • Secondary: ISO C99 (ISO/IEC 9899:1999)
  • Tertiary: ISO C11 (for modern features)
  • Validation: GCC/Clang behavior for undefined cases

Progress Tracking

Weekly Updates

Update this checklist every Friday with:

  • Constructs completed this week
  • Coverage % change
  • Unsafe block count change
  • Blocked tasks (with reasons)
  • Next week priorities

Monthly Reviews

Monthly roadmap review (first Monday):

  • Sprint completion percentage
  • Velocity (story points/sprint)
  • Quality metrics trends
  • Adjust remaining sprints

Notes

Skipped Features (Out of Scope)

The following are intentionally NOT supported:

  • Inline Assembly: Too platform-specific, use FFI
  • VLA in structs: Safety issues, use Vec instead
  • Nested functions: GCC extension, not standard C
  • K&R style function declarations: Deprecated, C89+ only

Feature Flags

Some features may be behind feature flags:

  • unsafe-optimizations: Allow more unsafe for performance
  • c11-support: Enable C11-specific features
  • gcc-extensions: Support GCC-specific extensions

Summary

Remaining Work: 34 constructs, 158 story points Estimated Time: 5 sprints (10 weeks) Target Completion: Sprint 12 (95% coverage) Current Velocity: ~30 story points/sprint

Critical Path:

  1. Preprocessor (14 tasks) - Enables header file parsing
  2. File I/O (1 task) - Completes Chapter 7
  3. Advanced features (13 tasks) - Covers edge cases
  4. C99/C11 features (5 tasks) - Modern C support

Last Updated: 2025-10-19 Maintained by: Claude Code + PMAT Methodology: EXTREME TDD + Toyota Way